Why Goalies Make Good Captains

Look at who wears the C on a college lacrosse team often enough and a pattern shows up. A disproportionate number of them are goalies.

Coaches will tell you it's because the goalie sees the whole field. That's part of it and it isn't the interesting part.

The interesting part is that this position quietly requires a thirteen-year-old to do the four hardest things in leadership — every Saturday, whether or not he feels like it — years before anybody offers him a title.

The short version

He directs people. Calling the ball, setting the slide, organising a ride. Out loud, at volume, to teammates who are frequently older and bigger.

He takes responsibility in public. The mistake goes on a scoreboard with his name effectively under it, and he stands there anyway.

He stays functional when it's going badly. A team down four looks at the goalie first. What they see decides the next ten minutes.

And he does the unglamorous job. The one nobody volunteered for, week after week, without much credit.

That's not a list of goalie traits. That's a job description for leading anything.

What the position actually drills

Speaking with authority before he's earned it. This is the one that transfers hardest. A sixth-grade goalie has to tell an eighth grader where to go, right now, loudly, and be obeyed. Most kids are never asked to do anything like that, and the ones who are tend to be visibly different at sixteen.

Communicating under time pressure. Not a considered sentence — three words, at the right moment, that change what ten people do. A goalie who learns this is learning something a lot of adults never manage in meetings.

Reading a situation from outside it. He's the only player on the field facing the whole thing, and the only one whose job is to see the pattern rather than his own matchup. Ten years of that produces a habit of perspective.

Absorbing blame without passing it on. This is the quiet one, and it's where I think the position does its most important work. A goalie who blames his defense loses his defense inside a season. He learns fast that taking it and moving on is what keeps a group working — which is the failure article, wearing a different hat.

And modelling composure. He learns that his face is information. When he's rattled, the defense gets rattled, so he practises not showing it — not as suppression, but as a job he's doing for other people.

Suggestions on what you can do

Ask your young athlete about the talking, not the saves. What were you calling in the third? signals that you consider the communication part of the job to be the job. Over years, that's how he comes to see it that way too.

Let him be uncomfortable early. The first season he has to direct older kids will be awkward and he'll be too quiet. That's the work. Stepping in — telling his coach he needs help being heard — short-circuits the thing that's being built.

Notice when he's fair. If he defends a teammate after a bad slide, say something. That behaviour is leadership and it's invisible unless somebody names it.

Keep your own sideline conduct clean. He's watching how you talk about the refs, the coach and other people's kids. Whatever you do with blame, he'll do with blame — and the sideline article covers the rest.

And give him younger goalies to help. A fifteen-year-old showing a nine-year-old how to hold a stance is doing more leadership development in twenty minutes than any seminar provides, and the sport needs it badly.

By age: third and fourth grade, the whole goal is that he makes a sound — "ball" and "check" is enough. Fifth and sixth, learning the actual vocabulary of directing a defense, which is golden-age work like everything else. Seventh and eighth, volume and authority, which is where this program starts tracking it deliberately. Ninth and tenth, leading people who didn't choose him and may not like him, which is the real version. Eleventh and twelfth, the captain's job proper: setting a standard when he's tired and nobody's watching.

A few things worth avoiding

Try not to push for a captaincy. A title arranged by a parent is worth nothing to a kid and costs him standing with his team.

Go easy on the loudness-equals-leadership idea. Plenty of the best goalie captains are quiet people who say the right three words. Volume on the field is a technical requirement; leadership isn't the same thing.

Try not to let him lead by criticism. A goalie who organises by complaining about teammates is building a habit that will follow him, and it's correctable at twelve and awkward at twenty.

And don't expect it to look like leadership yet. At eleven it looks like a kid yelling "ball" in a squeaky voice. That's the beginning of it.

The version worth remembering

Nobody sets out to teach a child to direct people under pressure, take the blame publicly, and stay calm when it's falling apart.

This position does it by accident, forty Saturdays a year, for ten years — and whatever your goalie ends up doing for a living, that's likely to be the part of lacrosse he actually uses.

---

Leadership is built into the program as trained content — a Leadership Ledger in middle school, a Captain's Voice in the last two years — rather than left to chance. Three real days of a fifth-grade week are open on the site, no signup. Take a look at the free week.

Coach Greg — LAX Goalie Hub